AIPGMEE 2015

Salmonella infections in resource-rich countries are almost always acquired by ingestion of contaminated food. This is because:

• There is a large reservoir of Salmonella in animals, especially poultry.
• Salmonella is relatively sensitive to stomach acid, so only large numbers of bacteria can establish infection.
• Salmonella may be shed in the feces for several weeks after an infection has resolved, facilitating food contamination.
• Water treatment suppresses infection due to drinking contaminated water.
• All of the above statements are correct.

In resource poor countries, Salmonella can be spread by contaminated water. In discussing routes of infection, it is interesting to contrast Salmonella with Shigella infections. Shigella is much more resistant to stomach acid, and so infections can be caused by a small number of organisms. This greatly facilitates spread of shigellosis in settings such as day care centers, where fecal-oral transmission occurs via contaminated surfaces.

AIPGMEE 2015

Which of the following conditions is most likely to produce a murmur in early diastole?

• Ventricular septal defect (VSD)
• Mitral stenosis
• Tricuspid regurgitation
• Aortic regurgitation
• Pulmonary stenosis

The murmurs of VSD, tricuspid regurgitation and pulmonary stenosis all occur in systole. Mitral stenosis typically produces a mid-diastolic murmur. The soft early diastolic murmur of aortic regurgitation is best heard with the patient sitting forward in held expiration, and is often described as ‘the absence of silence’ following the second heart sound. The link below provides a comprehensive guide to the evaluation of heart murmurs.

AIPGMEE 2015

A female newborn has a single perineal orifice. The chance that this baby has associated urologic problems is:

• <10%
• 30%
• 60%
• 90%
• None of the above

More than 90% of the time the diagnosis in girls can be established on perineal inspection. The presence of a single perineal orifice is a cloaca. Patients with a persistent cloaca have a 90% risk of urologic defects. (See Chapter 336, page 1358.Nelson Pediatrics 19th edn)

AIPGMEE 2015

A heart murmur is noted during the preschool physical examination of a 4-year-old girl. An echocardiogram reveals a defect between the right and left atrium involving the limbus of the foramen ovale. What is the most likely diagnosis?

• Atrial septal defect (ASD), ostium primum
• ASD, ostium secundum
• Tetralogy of Fallot
• Truncus arteriosus
• Ventricular septal defect

Ostium secundum: type ASD accounts for 90% of all ASDs. It reflects a true deficiency of the atrial septum and should not be confused with patent foramen ovale. Ostium secundum defects commonly occur in the middle portion of the septum and vary in size from a trivial opening to a large defect of the entire fossa ovalis. A small ASD is unlikely to be functional, but left-to-right shunting may occur in large defects, causing dilation and hypertrophy of the right atrium and ventricle. The ostium primum anomaly occurs adjacent to the AV valves and is usually associated with a cleft anterior mitral leaflet. Ventricular septal defect (choice E) occurs in the interventricular septum. The diagnoses in choices C and D are characterized by multiple congenital abnormalities and early cyanosis.
Diagnosis: Atrial septal defect

AIPGMEE 2015

1. This is a multiplicative effect between exposure variables
   1. Biologic plausibility
   2. Confounder
   3. Effect modifier
   4. External validity
   5. Internal validity
   6. Intervening variable
   7. Measurement bias
   8. Necessary cause
   9. Recall bias
   10. Sufficient cause
   11. Synergism
        Answer K
2. When the combined effect of two or more variables on an outcome is greater than the sum of the separate effects of the variables, their interaction is called synergy or synergism. Cigarette smoking and asbestos exposure have a synergistic effect on the risk of lung cancer.† If the relative risk or risk ratio for lung cancer in smokers is X and if the relative risk for lung cancer in asbestos workers is Y, the relative risk in those with both exposures is closer to X × Y than to X + Y.

AIPGMEE 2015

1. 1. Epidemiology is broadly defined as the study of factors that influence the health of populations. The application of epidemiologic findings to decisions in the care of individual patients is:
   A.    Generally inappropriate
   B.     Known as clinical epidemiology
   C.     Limited to chronic disease epidemiology
   D.    Limited to infectious disease epidemiology
   E.     Limited to biologic mechanisms rather than social and environmental considerations
   Answer
   B. Clinical practice is devoted to the care of individual patients. Outcomes in individual patients in response to clinical interventions cannot be known, however, until after the interventions have been tried. The basis for choosing therapy (or for choosing diagnostic tests) is prior experience in similar patients, rather than knowledge of what would work best for the individual. The use of clinically applied statistics, probability, and population-based data to inform medical decisions is known as clinical epidemiology. Clinical epidemiology pertains to all clinical care. Its findings and applications are not limited to infectious diseases (D) or chronic diseases (C), or to biologic mechanisms (E). Social and environmental considerations are very relevant to clinical decision making (E). Far from being inappropriate (A), the application of epidemiologic principles to patient care is fundamental to evidence-based practice and is supportive of robust clinical decisions.
   2.      Tim has a severe heart attack at age 58. The near-death experience so scares Tim that he quits smoking. Tim’s wife is also scared into quitting smoking even though she feels fine. Tim’s son resolves never to start smoking, seeing what cigarettes have done to his dad. The act of not smoking for Tim, Tim’s wife, and Tim’s son represents:
   A.    Host, vector, and agent effects, respectively
   B.     Herd immunity
   C.     Tertiary prevention for Tim’s son
   D.    Tertiary prevention, primary prevention, and secondary prevention, respectively
   E.     Tertiary prevention, secondary prevention, and primary prevention, respectively
   Answer
   E. Prevention means intervening to interrupt the natural history of disease. Primary prevention represents the earliest possible interventions to foil disease before it even begins (e.g., Tim’s son never starting to smoke). Secondary prevention is thwarting the progression of established disease that has not yet declared itself with symptoms or outward signs (e.g., Tim’s asymptomatic wife quitting smoking). Tertiary prevention is slowing, arresting, or even reversing obvious or symptomatic disease to prevent worsening symptoms and further deterioration (e.g., Tim quitting smoking after his heart attack). Answer choices (C) and (D) get distinctions between these stages of disease prevention wrong. Herd immunity (B) is the prevention of disease transmission to susceptible individuals through acquired immunity in others. Herd immunity does not apply to the scenario involving Tim and his family. Likewise, definitions for host (i.e., susceptible individual), vector (i.e., unaffected carrier), and agent (i.e., medium of harm) (A) do not apply to the characterizations of Tim and his family.
   
   

AIPGMEE 2015

A 73-year-old man collapses at home following a stroke. He is found 24 hours later, still lying on the floor. On admission to hospital he appears only mildly dehydrated but is in acute renal failure. He is treated with i.v. fluids but remains oliguric and his renal function continues to deteriorate. Dipstick urinalysis is strongly positive for blood but microscopy reveals no red cells. What is the most likely diagnosis?

• Renal calculus
• Urinary sepsis
• Rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis
• Renal infarction
• Rhabdomyolysis

All of the options listed could conceivably account for deteriorating renal function accompanied by dipstick-positive haematuria, but the absence of red cells on microscopy is characteristic of myoglobinuria occurring as a consequence of rapid muscle breakdown. This patient is at risk of rhabdomyolysis from having lain on the floor for 24 hours.

More on Interpretation of dipstick-positive haematuria (p. 479)